A Maleficent Reaction

This post may contain affiliate links; please read the disclosure for more information.

Update: 12/29/11 Patrick got a positive response from the Disney Store soon after we posted this article: Just to give you an update, DS.com has giving me the option of returning for credit, full refund or keep it and get 15% off.  I chose for the refund naturally.

We just posted an article pointing out the difference in how certain NOAH Vinylmation are advertised. Along those lines, we received an email from a listener Patrick who purchased the $650 NOAH Vault 28 Online exclusive 9″ Hand Painted Limited Release Maleficent Vinylmation. Here is what he wrote:

I recently just received my Custom Noah Maleficent from DS.com. I was very excited and looking forward to this piece ever since I saw preview photographs of it from the Villains Event back in November at Disneyland.

NOAH 9″ Maleficent on display at Villains Event at DLR
NOAH holding the 9″ Maleficent he designed

After opening and looking at my NEW Noah. I noticed something didn’t look right. The colors for the flames and Dragon weren’t as vibrant as what Noah showed off at the event and what was advertised on DS.com. I really felt mislead by Disney and Noah.

Picture from product page on DisneyStore.com

Notice how vibrant the yellow flames and dragon are. The colors pop out to you. The flames are even bigger and filled. Now if you look at the piece I have received, the piece is very dark and monochromatic. I need to shine a very bright light close up to see the piece or take it outside in the bright sun. The flames and dragon head yellows are very flat.

9″ NOAH Maleficent Patrick received in mail
9″ NOAH Maleficent Patrick received in mail

Also if you look back at the Villains Rotten Apple Piece, the “V” on the face is totally different from what he previewed. You can even see the Preview “V” on his website. It looks totally different from what he sold. At least that piece, I saw what I was buying so I accepted the difference. With Maleficent I had no choice.

As you know, DS.com accepts no refunds, exchanges or returns. If you read the reviews on the product page, I’m not the only one not satisfied about this piece. Spending money on these customs are not cheap. I think I should get for what I was showed and paid for.

That was the email we received from Patrick. We would like to note, that the Disney Store does state that no two of these NOAH Vinylmation will be exactly the same. However, based on the pictures he gave us, the product Patrick received seems to have a significantly different final look than the advertised product.

Did anyone else get the NOAH Maleficent Vinyl Online?

(Below is a screen capture of the three reviews posted on the Disney Store as of 12/28/11. Click to enlarge.)


About the author

Nick LoCicero

Nick LoCicero has almost 20 years experience in the media industry. He has worked on numerous Disney related media projects, most know at WDWNT for WDW News Tonight. He has been visiting Walt Disney World since 1982. After moving to Orlando in the late 90's he became a passholder, developed a fascination with the history of the vacation kingdom and has spent way too much money on park merchandise.

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Shannyn
Guest
Shannyn

That’s really dissapointing. The pictures don’t look at all like the ones they mailed out. Just look at the colors of the mouths!

Rust
Guest
Rust

Wow that’s a bummer. I would be livid if I spent $650 on that’s what I got.

I also think that part of why it seems so dark is the glossy finish they added, which reflects most of the light instead of absorb it or dispersing it evenly across the surface. The one in the photo online looks like it has a matte finish. But the green color is definitely a much darker tint than the original, and is the only color, whereas the original had yellow and green.

vinylone
Guest
vinylone

I would be upset too! This vinyl does not match one pictured — DS.com should give everyone that ordered this vinyl a refund if requested.

MinnieYooHoo
Guest
MinnieYooHoo

I’m so sorry, what a disappointment :( But I can’t say I’m surprised at this. I have seen some of his vinyl works (Disneyland’s 55th 9″, D23 Expo, Muppets) and I don’t really see what the big deal is with his stuff. The Muppets-Kermit & Animal, 3″ and 9″ at D Street-are ridiculous! $150 for a 3″ vinyl that was simply painted green (unless they started out green, then that’s even more ridiculous!) and then accented with what looks like a paint pen for Kermit’s collar and a kiss on his forehead (Piggy’s?-still, weird choice) You must be joking! Really,… Read more »

solo.dancer
Guest
solo.dancer

okay, did they not say that the colors would end up being different on each of these?

Rust
Guest
Rust

No where on the page does it say that it will look different than the one pictured http://www.disneystore.com/vinylmation-online-exclusive-vault-28-villains-maleficent-9-vinylmation-figure-by-noah/mp/1299372/1000828/

They even say that the flames will be “vivid lime green”, which the actually flames are more of a pale turquoise.