Following our experiences at the WWE Presents: The Horrors of the Wyatt Sicks house for Halloween Horror Nights 2025, we are back to try some dishes and beverages from the nearby food booth. Do the flavors live up to the twisted terror? Let’s check it out.
WWE Presents: The Horrors of The Wyatt Sicks Food Booth
Location
The WWE Presents: The Horrors of the Wyatt Sicks booth is located on Park Avenue in New York, facing Gramercy Park.
Menu
Food:
- Huskus’ Muscle Man Slop – $14.99
- Ramblin’ Rabbit Fried Carrot Cake – $8.99
Beverages:
- Light the Way – $18 for 20 oz. souvenir cup | $14 for souvenir refill | $14 for 12 oz. single serving
- LET ME IN Mocktail – $9
Reviews
Huskus’ Muscle Man Slop – $14.99
Beef sloppy joe with jalapeño bacon, LAY’S Dill Pickle Flavored Potato Chips, and cheese sauce on a chocolate almond bun
Nothing about this sloppy joe makes sense, but in a way that works with the theme. It is a crazy mess that comes together to confuse you, but somehow delight you at the same time. Despite featuring a number of flavors that normally have no business being together, we actually enjoyed it.
The meat itself is a main highlight. The chocolate bun makes for a good story, but we think a regular bun may have elevated this even further. Still, this is a dish we thoroughly enjoyed eating and would order again.
Rating out of 7: 5
Ramblin’ Rabbit Fried Carrot Cake – $8.99
Crispy carrot cake with white icing and torn ramblin’ rabbit cotton candy
In keeping with a running food theme, this is another take on a classic dish. Every risk they took with the classic carrot cake, such as the crispy exterior, absolutely paid off. This would be near the top of our favorite theme park carrot cake dishes.
The cotton candy to the side did not add a ton of flavor, but it didn’t need to. The cake stands on its own, and the cotton candy adds some color to the presentation. Much like Bray Wyatt himself, we expect this to have a cult following.
Rating out of 7: 7
Light the Way – $18 for 20 oz. souvenir cup | $14 for souvenir refill | $14 for 12 oz. single serving
Firefly White Lightnin’ moonshine, Firefly Peach moonshine, Sūpāsawā, blue Curaçao syrup, simple syrup and Seagram’s tonic water
At first taste, this reminded us of the Quantum Mocktail we reviewed over at the Fallout booth. However, this one has a better mix of ingredients, plus a stronger presentation. We found what the Quantum was missing.
Rating out of 7: 5
LET ME IN Mocktail – $9
Lemon juice, peach puree, simple syrup and lavender syrup, garnished with a dragon fruit syrup float
There is nothing particularly notable in this drink. There is a strong peach flavor, and the globs of bottom-dwelling syrup refuse to get stirred into the rest of the liquid. We didn’t actively dislike it, but it doesn’t stand out as something special.
Rating out of 7: 4
Overall Thoughts
While the menu at The Horrors of the Wyatt Sicks booth seems a bit experimental to read on paper, the vast majority of the food and beverage offerings are hits. We would go out of our way to grab that carrot cake again, though all of the items sit comfortably in our upper half of the HHN food for 2025. Face your fears and give it a try!
For more Universal Studios news from around the world, follow Universal Parks News Today on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram. For Disney Parks news, visit WDWNT.