REVIEW: Carrot Cake Cookie Altered in Move to Trolley Car Cafe at Disney’s Hollywood Studios

This post may contain affiliate links; please read the disclosure for more information.

Sweet Spells, the candy store and bake shop on Sunset Boulevard in Disney’s Hollywood Studios, recently closed. This location was the only spot in the park to purchase fudge, candy apples, and as of this past year, the infamous carrot cake cookie. The carrot cake cookie was originally located at Writer’s Stop, which closed to be converted into Baseline Tap House. With the closing of Sweet Spells, the future of the cookie was uncertain, but fortunately, it reappeared at the park’s Starbucks location, Trolley Car Cafe.

Carrot Cake Cookie – $3.99

The cookie looks very different than its previous incarnations; it’s much thicker with a smaller circumference now. Even with the presentation change, the flavor profile remains pretty much the same. We assume the change had to be made to accommodate a different kitchen set-up wherever they are making these now.

The cake is perfectly spiced and cooked to have a crispy exterior and cakey interior. Expect a sweet cream cheese in the middle that goes to all of the edges evenly, making each bite wonderful. Fans of the previous version of the carrot cake cookie will definitely enjoy this (we maybe even liked it a little more since the cream cheese was better distributed in the new shape without thin cookie edges).

About the author

Topher Wallace

Contact Topher at [email protected]

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Tate
Guest
Tate

Does it still have raisins in the cake part?

Peter
Guest
Peter

Man they totally cut down on the amount of cream cheese frosting stuffed between the carrot cake “cookies”

Keith
Guest
Keith

“infamous”???…was there something wicked about the cookie? I always thought it was pretty good. Maybe the name was offensive to redheads?

Cynthia
Guest
Cynthia

I couldn’t agree more with Peter. The carrot cake “cookie” was my go-to snack favorite. So much so, that I would specifically bring tupperware with me & horde a bunch to bring home. I tried the new “cookie” (it still bugs me that they call this a cookie) last week. The taste is identical, so no change there which is great. What isn’t great is that there the ratio of cream cheese frosting in the center now seems to be waaayyy lacking. There was definitely more filling in the old version & I hope they fix this soon!

Tom Corless
Admin
Tom Corless

I felt it was the other was around, there were many bites without it around the edges on the old one.