REVIEW: NEW Butter Butter, Everything Everything, and More Breakfast Sandwiches at Boardwalk Bakery

This post may contain affiliate links; please read the disclosure for more information.

The Boardwalk Bakery has added a slew of new breakfast sandwiches to appease the masses. Available only in the morning, four brand new sandwiches are set to be the Everything Everything of your day.


Ooey Gooey – Artisan Roll, Cage-Free Egg, Cheddar, Mozzarella, Capicola, and Oven-Dried Tomato – $8.79

It’s large and in charge. Unfortunately it just doesn’t work well. The ham has a spice to it that ruins the entire sandwich. It’s large enough to share if you can get past the offputting flavor, but it’s a lot to get past.


Oh That’s So Cheesey – Whole Grain Sunflower and Oat Bread, Scrambled Eggs, Bacon, Tomato, Smoked Gouda, Cheddar, and Provolone – $6.79

Oh it’s cheesey alright. There’s a lot going on and the sandwich holds-up well amongst the craziness. We originally thought this was the best sandwich of the morning but it doesn’t hold a candle to the Butter Butter…


Butter Butter Sandwich – Brioche Bread, Shaved Ham, Scrambled Eggs, and Buttery Fontina Cheese Spread – $6.79

BUTTER BUTTER! This sandwich is gooey and full of ham and cheese and a wonderful butter spread. It gets better towards the middle where all of the ingredients culminate to a breakfast bonanza. It’s the best sandwich here!


Everything Everything Sandwich – Everything Bagel, Cage-Free Fried Egg, and Tillamook Cheddar – $5.49

This one included bacon. We were asked 3 times when ordering if we wanted bacon as an upcharge, we said no. Still we received bacon. If you’re a bagel snob stay away, but if this is a relatively enjoyable sandwich that’s pretty large. The only downside is how fresh the bagel can be, and knowing Disney that’s a gamble.


About the author

Topher Wallace

Contact Topher at [email protected]

newest oldest most voted
Notify of

Ehh. I really was looking for the caged eggs….they are just so much more tender.