REVIEW: Lobster Fried Green Tomatoes, Kentucky Hot Turkey, and Steak from New Dinner Menu at The Plaza Restaurant, Magic Kingdom

the plaza restaurant magic kingdom walt disney world dinner review january 2019
This post may contain affiliate links; please read the disclosure for more information.

The Plaza Restaurant is a table service restaurant located at the end of Main Street, U.S.A. in Magic Kingdom. This location is well-known for its classic 1970’s charm, bottomless milkshakes, and most recently, for its luxurious breakfast spread. We stopped in one of these chilly evenings for a bite, so read on to find out we thought about their new-ish dinner offerings which debuted in December. Dinner is offered from 3pm to 9pm daily.

The Plaza Restaurant – Dinner Menu

the plaza restaurant magic kingdom walt disney world dinner review january 2019

the plaza restaurant magic kingdom walt disney world dinner review january 2019

the plaza restaurant magic kingdom walt disney world dinner review january 2019

Lobster Fried Green Tomatoes – $13.00

the plaza restaurant magic kingdom walt disney world dinner review january 2019
Lobster Fried Green Tomatoes – Deep Fried Green Tomato served on a bed of Arugula with tender Lobster meat, topped with an Alabama White Barbeque Sauce and Green Onions and Parsley.

We started with these based on how good the Lobster Eggs Benedict is at breakfast. They offer a nice bit of lobster and the fried green tomatoes were much more enjoyable than the first time we had them a few years back. Everything tasted fresh and the white barbecue sauce pulled it all together nicely.

the plaza restaurant magic kingdom walt disney world dinner review january 2019

Kentucky Turkey Hot Brown Sandwich – $18.00

the plaza restaurant magic kingdom walt disney world dinner review january 2019
Kentucky Turkey Hot Brown Sandwich – Lightly battered grilled Texas Toast layer with Oven Roasted Turkey Breasts, Applewood Bacon, seasoned Grilled Tomato smothered with our creamy Boursin cheese. Topped off with melted Parmesan Cheese and fresh Chives.

With the $18 Chicken and Waffles gone from Ale and Compass, this is now the best table service dinner value at Walt Disney World, in my opinion. The juicy, grilled tomato is covered in Boursin cheese, bacon, and parmesan, laid over the nicely roasted turkey, which is on top of a grilled Texas Toast that is simply to die for. The flavor combination is really amazing if you like such things and the portion size is monstrous. Highly recommended.

the plaza restaurant magic kingdom walt disney world dinner review january 2019

Strip Steak – $32.00

the plaza restaurant magic kingdom walt disney world dinner review january 2019
Strip Steak – A grilled-to-order 10-oz N.Y. Strip Steak seasoned with an in-house blend seasoning and basted with Garlic Butter. Served with tender Broccolini and a Cheesy Bacon Twice-Baked Potato.

Well, it’s a Magic Kingdom strip steak. It’s not great, but it isn’t bad either. If you’re ordering a steak here, you’re better off going elsewhere. I know people like to get their money’s worth out of the Dining Plan, but you should also eat something good. The star of the plate was the cheesy twice-baked potato which trumps most similar sides we’ve had anywhere else at Walt Disney World.

the plaza restaurant magic kingdom walt disney world dinner review january 2019

I know it doesn’t look great in the picture, but the cheese layer holds in a freshly twice-baked potato. A twice baked potato is a potato that has first been fully cooked in the oven. The white potato interior is then scooped out, to leave the potato skin as the ‘shell.’ Then the potato interior is mixed with fillings such as butter, sour cream, cheese and bacon.

the plaza restaurant magic kingdom walt disney world dinner review january 2019

OVERALL 

There are some hits and some misses, but the menu isn’t a total quality shift from what you might expect from the Plaza. That being said, I think the expectation at Plaza Restaurant is a menu with more traditional burgers and sandwiches, so I wouldn’t be surprised if some guests are upset with the change. Either way, I’ll be back for the above turkey sandwich.

About the author

Tom Corless

Tom has been regularly visiting the Walt Disney World® Resort from the time he was 4 months old. While he has made countless visits in the last 28 years, he did not become a truly active member in the Disney fan community until the summer of 2007, when he decided to launch the WDW News Today website and podcast. Tom has since become an Orlando-local and is a published author on Walt Disney World.
Contact Tom at [email protected]