REVIEW: Fantasmic!-Themed Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwich Debuts at Disney’s Hollywood Studios

You don’t have to dream a fantastic dream or search your imagination for a Fantasmic!-themed Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwich. It’s available now from Rosie’s All American Café at Disney’s Hollywood Studios in Walt Disney World.

Rosie's All American Café has a new peanut butter cookie sandwich.

Rosie’s All American Café on Sunset Boulevard offers a traditional ordering line as well as mobile order.

Rosie's All American Café has a new peanut butter cookie sandwich.

This dining location opens at 10:00 a.m. and shutters its windows at park close.

Rosie's All American Café has a new peanut butter cookie sandwich.

Rosie’s All American Café is located just next to Catalina Eddie’s.

Rosie's All American Café has a new peanut butter cookie sandwich.

Rosie’s All American Café features kid-friendly selections including Chicken Breast Nuggets, an Angus Bacon Cheeseburger, and a Foot-long All-Beef Hot Dog.

Rosie's All American Café has a new peanut butter cookie sandwich.

On the menu board over the ordering window, the Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwich is showcased just above the Kids’ Meals.

Fantasmic!-Themed Peanut Butter Cookie Sandwich – $5.29

Pretzel Shortbread Cookie Sandwich with Strawberry Jam and Peanut Butter Chocolate Fudge and a Fantasmic! Chocolate Piece.

Rosie's All American Café has a new peanut butter cookie sandwich.

A white chocolate piece sits atop the confection. It illustrates Sorcerer Mickey and the Maleficent dragon, as featured in the “Fantasmic!” show now open again in Disney’s Hollywood Studios.

Rosie's All American Café has a new peanut butter cookie sandwich.

A thick “pretzel” cookie sits below the chocolate piece, adhered by a smear of strawberry jam and peanut butter chocolate fudge. Based on our tasting, we’re not really sure what makes this shortbread cookie anything like a pretzel, but it’s good.

Rosie's All American Café has a new peanut butter cookie sandwich.

The white chocolate piece on top is okay; it’s just a piece of white chocolate. It didn’t present any additional flavors or wow us in any way. The print of Mickey and Maleficent came off on our fingers, and it does stain, so beware of that. We personally took this piece off after the initial bite and did not eat it.

Rosie's All American Café has a new peanut butter cookie sandwich.

Alone, the pretzel shortbread cookie has a great flavor. It’s not overpowering at all. It has a light peanut butter flavor, and some peanut bits are spread throughout out the cookie. This gives it a nice crunch. It’s soft and baked well.

Rosie's All American Café has a new peanut butter cookie sandwich.

The strawberry jam and peanut butter fudge blend really well with the cookie. The strawberry jam has a nice consistency. It’s not too gummy or sticky.

Rosie's All American Café has a new peanut butter cookie sandwich.

The peanut butter chocolate fudge has a strong peanut butter chocolate flavor all on its own. It does pair nicely with the jam and the cookie. 

If you like peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, you’ll like this cookie. We would get this again. We actually preferred this over the Lunch Box Tarts at Woody’s Lunch Box.

Will you be tasting one of these peanut butter and jelly-inspired cookie sandwiches? Do you like it more or less than a Lunch Box Tart at Woody’s Lunch Box? Tell us all your thoughts in the comments below.

For the latest Disney Parks news and info, follow WDW News Today on TwitterFacebook, and Instagram.

Author

  • Lisa Stump

    Lisa loves theme parks, black coffee, and her two Sphynx cats, Jareth and Figment. She believes the best day includes a trip around World Showcase during the EPCOT International Food & Wine festival! Her favorite attractions are Rise of the Resistance, Guardians of the Galaxy: Cosmic Rewind, and "it's a small world." She can be reached at lisa.stum[email protected].