REVIEW: Not-So-Poison Apple Churro, ‘The Nightmare Before Christmas’ Jack and Sally Pops at Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party 2023

Katie Francis

REVIEW: Not-So-Poison Apple Churro, ‘The Nightmare Before Christmas’ Jack and Sally Pops at Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party 2023

Katie Francis

REVIEW: Not-So-Poison Apple Churro, ‘The Nightmare Before Christmas’ Jack and Sally Pops at Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party 2023

Guests can find the Not-So-Poison Apple Churro plus “The Nightmare Before Christmas” Jack and Sally Pops exclusively at Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party 2023.

Magic Kingdom Cinderella Castle Hub East Cart
Magic Kingdom Cinderella Castle Hub West Cart

You can find the churro at the cart to the east of Cinderella Castle in the castle hub, and the cake pops at the cart to the west.

Castle Churro and Popcorn Carts MNSSHP 2023 Menu

Not So Poison Apple Churro Menu Card
Jack and Sally Cake Pop Menu Card
  • 🆕 Not-So-Poison Apple Churro – $7
  • 🆕 Jack Pop – $5.75
  • 🆕 Sally Pop – $5.75

*NEW* Not-So-Poison Apple Churro – $7

Churro rolled in green apple sugar, topped with SNICKERS bar pieces, and drizzled with caramel sauce 

Not So Poison Apple Churro

The apple and Snickers flavors are a great combination, but unfortunately, our churro was extremely stale. Walt Disney World continues to lag behind Disneyland when it comes to churros.

Not So Poison Apple Churro

That being said, putting these flavors together is a great idea, and we hope to see them again, minus the stale churro.

Not So Poison Apple Churro

We also have to mention that the east cart sells the party-exclusive Nightmare Before Christmas popcorn bucket, which makes the line a lengthy wait just to get a mediocre churro.

*NEW* Jack Pop – $5.75

Chocolate fudge brownie with marshmallow filling and topped with a Jack chocolate piece

Jack Cake Pop

This Jack cake pop is a fudge brownie, but it’s not as dense and rich as you’d think.

Jack Cake Pop

The coating seems to be flavorless fondant instead of frosting or a chocolate dip. It peeled off in places and was not great.

Jack Cake Pop

The white chocolate medallion was pretty much what you’d expect: forgettable.

*NEW* Sally Pop – $5.75

Yellow pop with raspberry filling topped with a Sally chocolate piece

Sally Cake Pop

The coating around the Sally cake pop is similar and slightly more pleasant than that of the Jack cake pop.

Sally Cake Pop

This cake pop also has a raspberry filling, though that filling is somewhat uneven.

Sally Cake Pop

As with the Jack version, the white chocolate medallion here can and should be skipped. The overall flavor of this treat was decent, though.

Magic Kingdom Cinderella Castle Hub East Cart

In addition, the party-exclusive popcorn bucket is also sold at this cart, making the wait for these cake pops a huge time commitment with a mostly forgettable payoff.

Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party runs from August 11 through November 1 on select nights. A separate ticket is required to attend.

Will you be looking for Jack & Sally, or seek the new churro? Let us know in the comments.

For the latest Disney Parks news and info, follow WDW News Today on TwitterFacebook, and Instagram.