REVIEW: Apple Fritter Sundae & Customizable Halloween Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich at Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

Katie Francis

REVIEW: Apple Fritter Sundae & Customizable Halloween Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich at Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

Katie Francis

REVIEW: Apple Fritter Sundae & Customizable Halloween Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich at Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party

Plaza Ice Cream Parlor is offering two fall-themed treats exclusively at Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party: an Apple Fritter Sundae and a Halloween Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich.

main street halloween decorations 2023 3069

The Plaza Ice Cream Parlor is at the end of Main Street, U.S.A. facing the hub.

Plaza Ice Cream Parlor MNSSHP 2023 Menu

Mickeys Not So Scary Halloween Party 2023 Apple Fritter Sundae and Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich 2
Mickeys Not So Scary Halloween Party 2023 Apple Fritter Sundae and Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich 5
  • 🆕 Apple Fritter Sundae – $8.29
  • Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich – $7.29

*NEW* Apple Fritter Sundae – $8.29

Apple fritters topped with choice of ice cream, whipped cream, and sprinkles

Mickeys Not So Scary Halloween Party 2023 Apple Fritter Sundae and Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich 10

If these are the same apple fritters as those from the Auntie Gravity’s Apple Fritter Milk Shake, they are on the bottom and ice cream is piled on top. This gives the ice cream a chance to soak through and soften up the fritters.

Mickeys Not So Scary Halloween Party 2023 Apple Fritter Sundae and Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich 12

You can choose your flavor of ice cream, and we went with vanilla for the most basic presentation. It’s all topped with whipped cream and black and orange sprinkles.

Halloween Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich – $7.29

Cookies topped with sprinkles with choice of ice cream

Mickeys Not So Scary Halloween Party 2023 Apple Fritter Sundae and Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich 11

The ice cream cookie sandwich is presented with little ghost, pumpkin, and bat sprinkles to up the fun a bit. Surprisingly, the cookie didn’t turn our hands black from food dye, though it still makes a mess when the ice cream comes out of the sides.

Mickeys Not So Scary Halloween Party 2023 Apple Fritter Sundae and Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich 9

This is a fun, delicious, and messy treat. We normally would’ve gone with a more fun ice cream flavor, but chose to keep it basic with vanilla this time around.

Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party runs from August 11 through November 1 on select nights. A separate ticket is required to attend.

For the latest Disney Parks news and info, follow WDW News Today on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram.