REVIEW: Peanut Butter Cold Brew Cookie Returns for May 2024 at Gideon’s Bakehouse

Brit Tuttle

REVIEW: Peanut Butter Cold Brew Cookie Returns for May 2024 at Gideon’s Bakehouse

A new month means new (or returning) treats at Gideon’s Bakehouse, and the Peanut Butter Cold Brew Cookie has made its return for May 2024 at Disney Springs.

May 2024 Cookie of the Month at Gideon’s Bakehouse

A person holds up a Gideon's Bakehouse postcard featuring a stylized character in front of the bakery's exterior on a sunny day.

Each month, alongside the new or returning cookie of the month, Gideon’s also introduces a new souvenir menu. This month’s menu features a black and white illustration of bookseller Jonathan Lindwurm.

A hand holding a menu for gideon's bakehouse, featuring a peanut butter cold brew cookie, in focus with blurred people and buildings in the background.

His backstory is printed on the back of the menu, which reads,

Antique photos can seem dark and mysterious, and so too can their subjects. In this case, both are true. Meet the enigmatic Jonathan Lindwurm — a brilliant and reclusive bookseller. Specializing in publications dealing with magic and alchemy, rumors quickly grew about his origins, with many claiming him to be from a different dimension altogether. Perhaps tired of the constant gossip, it’s said that Mr. Lindwurm entered his store one morning and was never seen again.

Peanut Butter Cold Brew Cookie – $6

Peanut butter cookie laced with freshly ground decaf espresso, covered in chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups and Reese’s Pieces

A reporter's hand holding the Peanut Butter Cold Brew Cookie for a close-up.

If you love all things peanut butter, then this limited-edition cookie is the one for you! The peanut butter flavor is prominent and takes over your taste buds. There are very small hints of chocolate in each bite, bringing sweetness to pair with the salt of the peanut butter.

A reporter's hand holding the Peanut Butter Cold Brew Cookie from Gideon's Bakehouse at an angle.

The ground espresso bean is overtaken by the peanut butter cookie. We aren’t getting any coffee flavoring.

A reporter holding the Peanut Butter Cold Brew Cookie broken in half to show its cross-section.

This cookie is delicious but grab some water or a nitro cold brew to help you wash it down.

Rank out of 7:

For the latest Disney Parks news and info, follow WDW News Today on TwitterFacebook, and Instagram.

View all posts

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.