REVIEW: Cookie Butter Butterscotch Cookie and Nitro Cold Brew NEW for January 2023 at Gideon’s Bakehouse in Disney Springs

It’s a new year, and Gideon’s Bakehouse has debuted a new flavor: Cookie Butter Butterscotch! We stopped by to try the cookie and nitro cold brew.

January 2023 Gideons Bakehouse Cookie Butter Butterscotch 20

January’s mascot is Butterscotch. Her story reads, “The moon holds strange powers, and so do the pajamas of a girl called Butterscotch. Handed down by her grandmother, this canine sleeper is said to awaken the wild nature of its wearer, and so, with the year’s first full moon, Butterscotch is transformed from a demure child into a rambunctious little terror. Jumping, howling, and growling, she tears about the woods all night. Then, at the light of day, she awakes as our sweet Butterscotch once more.”

January 2023 Gideons Bakehouse Cookie Butter Butterscotch 21

Frequent flyers at Gideon’s may be happy to know that the Banana Bread Chocolate Chip Cookie is now part of the regular menu and will be available daily.

January 2023 Gideons Bakehouse Cookie Butter Butterscotch 18

Cookie Butter Butterscotch Cookie – $6

Gideon’s Secret Recipe with Biscoff Cookie Butter, Butterscotch Chips, and crushed Biscoff Cookies

January 2023 Gideons Bakehouse Cookie Butter Butterscotch 11

Despite the heavy lean on Butterscotch in this month’s mascot, the predominant flavor here is Biscoff.

January 2023 Gideons Bakehouse Cookie Butter Butterscotch 14

It’s sweet but not overly sweet. As always, it’s perfectly baked and big enough to share.

January 2023 Gideons Bakehouse Cookie Butter Butterscotch 16

The butterscotch flavor is very subtle, but disappointingly so.

January 2023 Gideons Bakehouse Cookie Butter Butterscotch

We would eat one again but wouldn’t seek it out if there were other options.

Cookie Butter Butterscotch Nitro Cold Brew – $6

January 2023 Gideons Bakehouse Cookie Butter Butterscotch 3

We were told this would taste like a Butterbeer, but alas, it does not.

January 2023 Gideons Bakehouse Cookie Butter Butterscotch 6

This is a sugar-forward drink, and unlike the cookie, the butterscotch is heavy.

January 2023 Gideons Bakehouse Cookie Butter Butterscotch 5

It works well paired with the cookie, but it’s far too sugary for us. We’ll stick with the Peanut Butter Cold Brew (which is a must-have).

It’s unusual for Gideon’s Bakehouse, but both of these were a miss. There’s a Cookie Butter Butterscotch Cake Slice available on Wednesdays and Saturdays, but based on the other items, we wouldn’t go out of our way to try it out.

For the latest Disney Parks news and info, follow WDW News Today on TwitterFacebook, and Instagram.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.