shrimp fritters 4

REVIEW: New Shrimp Fritters Don’t Live Up to Classic Conch Fritters at Disney’s Old Key West Resort

Disney announced yesterday that Old Key West Resort would be replacing their classic conch fritters with shrimp fritters, in an effort to help support sustainable seafood initiatives. We visited Gurgling Suitcase Libations & Spirits today to try the new shrimp fritters.

gurgling suitcase

The fritters will also be served at Olivia’s Cafe.

gurgling suitcase 5

Appetizers at Gurgling Suitcase are available until 9:00 p.m., but the bar is open until 10:00 p.m. daily.

Shrimp Fritters – $13

shrimp fritters 4
shrimp fritters 9

Despite their appearance, these aren’t crispy. Instead, they’re slightly chewy.

shrimp fritters 7
shrimp fritters 11

It has pieces of shrimp, chives, and breading. The inside looked slightly underdone.

For more information on booking your next trip with our official travel agent sponsor, the Vacationeer, visit

vacationeer TopBarAD2020 v2
shrimp fritters 13
shrimp fritters 14

The shrimp isn’t fishy, and there’s a decent amount in there.

shrimp fritters 10
shrimp fritters 15

It comes with honey mustard, which is nice and sweet but overpowers the fritters.

shrimp fritters 12

They aren’t bad, but we wouldn’t reach for them again.

Will you miss the conch fritters from Disney’s Old Key West Resort? Let us know in the comments.

For the latest Disney Parks news and info, follow WDW News Today on TwitterFacebook, and Instagram.

  1. If you’ve ever visited the Keys, conch fritters are in every bar and restaurant. It was so cool to also have them at the Old Key West resort, such an authentic touch to a resort that already did such a nice job echoing the Keys.

    But why be authentic when you can be cheap?? That’s the new theme of Disney. (Get out of here with “sustainability” shrimp is cheaper.)

    I can’t wait for the key lime tart to be replaced with lemon pudding.

  2. The conch fritters are part of the “Key West” theme. The shrimp version just seems like another effort to cut corners. We like to go there and enjoy conch fritters and a cocktail. This is disappointing.

  3. We were sorely disappointed when we ordered the conch chowder at Goods To Go and were told it was no longer made. We were offered chicken noodle soup! Didn’t get the Old Key West vibe eating that on an 85 degree day!

Comments are closed.